The Majority Of Harvard’s Admitted 2021 Class Is Nonwhite — But Is That Something To Celebrate?
I went to college at a school that advertised itself as one of the most diverse in the country. When I arrived on campus, however, I realized that what amounted to “diversity” for this school was the recruitment of wealthy international students — and there rarely seemed to be any meaningful interaction between the international student body and the domestic one.
This is what came to mind when I saw a news story about Harvard’s incoming class. According to the admission numbers, Harvard’s accepted class was majority nonwhite (a previous headline on the original Boston Globe story mistakenly noted that it was the first time to happen — it’s, in fact, the second time. A correction clarified that Harvard has not yet “seated” a majority nonwhite class). Here’s the CNN breakdown:
“Of the 2,056 students accepted for the class of 2021, 50.8% do not identify as white. Of the admitted students, 22.2% are Asian-American, 14.6% are African-American, 11.6 are Latino, 1.9% are Native Americans, and Native Hawaiians are 0.5%. First-generation students make up 15.1% of the admitted class.”
These numbers, unfortunately, give no insight into the economic demographics of the admitted students, nor do they offer any insight into nationalities (we know of at least two wealthy women of color who made the cut — Harvard freshmen Malia Obama and Yara Shahidi). According to the Harvard website, international students comprise 12.4% of the newly admitted students, a significant portion (a Harvard representative we reached out to could not offer more information).
In 2011, writer Cord Jefferson wrote that it was the Ivy League’s “ dirty little secret” for inflating diversity statistics. “While America’s most elite colleges do in fact make it a point to promote ethnic diversity on their campuses, a lot of them do so by admitting hugely disproportionate numbers of wealthy immigrants and their children rather than black students with deep roots — and troubled histories — in the United States,” he wrote. While many universities have programs like Harvard’s Undergraduate Minority Recruitment Program, low-income students, for example, suffer from structural disadvantages that prevent them from entering schools like Harvard — economic struggles that keep them from being able to afford application fees and tuition or tutors and study aids.
The discussion on what qualifies as diversity is an important one to have, especially in light of recent events. Last week, the Trump administration announced it was pursuing an inquiry into “race-based discrimination” in college admissions, an investigation supposedly impelled by a complaint filed in 2015 by 64 Asian American groups who accused U.S. universities of imposing higher standards of entry for Asian students. It’s a development that has many social justice and equality advocates worried that the Department of Justice is using this complaint to justify a possible attack on affirmative action initiatives. It’s a misguided target, given that affirmative action policies benefit white woman more than any other demographic group.
Anytime I see a news story about diversity, I remember a talk by Angela Davis I attended at USC. “I have a hard time accepting diversity as a synonym for justice,” Davis told the audience back then. “Diversity is a corporate strategy. It’s a strategy designed to ensure that the institution functions in the same way that it functioned before, except now you have some black faces and brown faces. It’s a difference that doesn’t make a difference.”
Share image by Caroline Culler/Wikimedia Commons.
San Francisco Is The First U.S. City To Make Community College Free To All Residents A similar program in Tennessee is seeing positive results.
Print Still Matters — Especially For Students A new series of studies finds that reading from screens isn't great for classroom success.
This Group Is Tackling LGBTQ Youth Suicide Rates, One Text Message At A Time “It's a really critical issue for LGBTQ young people, and it's even more pressing and alarming in the current political climate.”
Why Some German Kindergartens Are Going Toy-Free Sounds cruel, doesn't it?
Study Shows Education Can Reduce Risk Of Alzheimer’s Disease “Older people who aren’t in the position to go back to school can reduce their Alzheimer’s risk by working longer.”
You’ll Need More Than Perfect Grades To Get Into America’s Top Universities “We should discard the notion that admissions is a meritocratic process that selects the 'best' 18-year-olds who apply to a selective university.”
Trump May Be The Reason More Students Are Choosing Historically Black Colleges And Universities “The atmosphere at HBCUs offer a space for students to grow and learn without necessarily having to factor that into their college experiences. It’s a safe space in a time where safety concerns and racial tension cannot be denied.”
American Children Continue To Fall Behind The Rest Of The World In Reading Comprehension The United States simply isn’t maintaining the same rate of progress that other countries are.
Lyft Wants To Help Its Drivers Finish College The ridesharing company is partnering with Guild Education to offer thousands of dollars in tuition discounts to drivers.